Permission to Appeal - March 2024

You may need to turn your phone when viewing table on mobile phone

Case Name	Justices	PTA	Reasons given
JCPC 2024/0003 Kimberly Francis (Appellant) v Royston John (Respondent) (Trinidad & Tobago) Neutral citation: FHP0024 of 2022	Lord Hodge Lord Stephens Lady Rose	Refused 15 March 2024	Permission to Appeal is refused because there is noarguable case of law.
JCPC 2024/0004 Lutchman Ramcharan (Appellant) v Vijay Mohan and another (Respondents) (Trinidad and Tobago) Neutral citation:	Lord Briggs Lord Sales Lord Hamblen	Refused 21 March 2024	Permission to Appeal is refused because this appeal is about concurrent findings of fact. There is no special circumstances justify it being heard by the JCPC. There is therefore no appeal as of right and no basis for special leave to appeal.
In the following cases, the advice which the Board has given to His Majesty is as indicated below
JCPC 2024/0002 Augusta Healt Care Inc (Respondent) v Valley Health System (Appellant) (Cayman Islands) Neutral citation:	Lord Lloyd-Jones Lord Burrows Lord Richards		Consideration deferred
JCPC 2023/0118 Soemarlie Lie (Respondent) v Ng Min Hong (Appellant) (Virgin Islands) Neutral citation:	Lord Briggs Lord Sales Lord Hamblen	Refused 21 March 2024	Permission to Appeal is refused because there is no arguable point of law.