Permission to Appeal

Permission to Appeal - March and April 2023

Permission to Appeal - March and April 2023

Case Name	Justices	PTA	Reasons given
Mitchell Fei Shing Li Pak Shong (Appellant) v The State of Mauritius (Respondent) (Mauritius) JCPC 2023/0004	Lord Lloyd-Jones Lord Burrows Lady Rose	Refused 17 April 2023	Permission to appeal be refused because there is no risk that as serious miscarriage of justice has occurred in this case.
Telecommunications Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (Respondent) v Amplia Communications Ltd (Appellant) (Trinidad and Tobago) JCPC 2022/0111 Telecommunications Authority of Trinidad and Tobago (Respondent) v Telecommunications Services of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd (Appellant) (Trinidad and Tobago) JCPC 2022/0112	Lord Hodge Lord Stephens Lord Richards	Refused 17 April 2023	Permission to appeal be refused because the applications do not raise an arguable point of law.
Donald Baldeosingh (Appellant) v Scotiabank Trinidad and Tobago Ltd (Respondent) (Trinidad and Tobago) JCPC 2023/0003	Lord Kitchin Lord Leggatt Lord Burrows	Refused 25 April 2023	Permission to appeal be refused because the appeal does not raise an arguable point of law and is devoid of merit.
In the following cases, the advice which the Board has given to His Majesty is as indicated below
GAC Holdings Ltd (Appellant) v Carl Stuart Jackson and three others (in their capacity as Joint Liquidators) (Respondents) (British Virgin Islands) JCPC 2022/0108	Lord Briggs Lord Kitchin Lord Hamblen	Refused 23 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because: There is no appeal as of right It is not a final decision in the relevant sense The application to court below was out of time There is no arguable point of law The appeal involves a challenge to concurrent findings of fact by the courts below The appeal is academic because the application into which joinder was sought has been dismissed
Janett Foster (Appellant) v Director of Public Prosecutions (Respondent) (Jamaica) JCPC 2022/0103	Lord Lloyd-Jones Lord Burrows Lady Rose	Refused 17 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because the appeal does not raise an arguable point of law.
Bilika Simamba (Appellant) v Attorney General of the Cayman Islands and another (Respondents) (Cayman Islands) JCPC 2022/0114	Lord Briggs Lord Stephens Lord Richards	Refused 17 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because the appeal does not raise an arguable point of law.
Julian Ellul (Appellant) v The King (Respondent) (Gibraltar) JCPC 2022/0113	Lord Reed Lord Sales Lord Leggatt	Refused 26 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because there is no risk that as serious miscarriage of justice has occurred in this case.
Millard Dunbar (Appellant) v St Catherine Co-Operative Credit Union (Respondent) (Jamaica) JCPC 2023/0014	Lord Kitchin Lord Leggatt Lord Burrows	Refused 15 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because the appeal does not raise an arguable point of law.
Jonathan Frank Edward Irving and another (Appellants) v Jeremy Paul Bradley Carter t/a Carters and another (Respondents) (Isle of Man) JCPC 2023/0009	Lord Lloyd-Jones Lord Kitchin Lord Stephans	Refused 15 May 2023	Permission to appeal should be refused because the appeal does not raise an arguable point of law.